Gavin Craig's Comic Reviews

Reviewer For: Comicosity Reviews: 49
8.3Avg. Review Rating

7.5
Animal Man (2011) #15

Dec 10, 2012

It would have been a bold move for a title less than a year old to put its main character's child into the lead role, but Lemire's built a supporting cast that could have handled it. It would have played hell with the larger DC continuity, but with Abby Arcane in a similar lead role in Swamp Thing it could have made for absolutely necessary reading in what were (and are) already two of the boldest, most gloriously weird titles in the New 52. And that sense of urgency and necessity are exactly what seem to be missing right now.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batgirl (2011) #14

Nov 15, 2012

Simone's Batgirl is kicking ass (in her nightshirt no less). I'd almost worry for the Joker.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman (2011) #0

Sep 12, 2012

But in a year of almost non-stop “holy crap” moments, there isn't really one in Batman #0. And I'm expecting (perhaps erroneously) that Batman #13 isn't going to pick up right where Batman #0 left off, meaning that it's going to be a while before I find out exactly whether and how the Red Hood delivers on the threat which ends the issue. It's going to be great, and I'm going to be there when it is. But I'm just a little surprised to say that Batman #0 doesn't quite get there on its own.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Batman (2011) #13

Oct 11, 2012

If you aren't reading Batman (and even with the sales figures, there must be at least a few of you), this is the perfect place to hop on board. And you should, if only to understand why your friends have started to look like they're not sleeping very well.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Batman (2011) #14

Nov 15, 2012

Snyder and Capullo promised big things in Death of the Family — the return and reinvention of Batman's most beloved adversary, a story that would encompass the entire Bat family, and a hero, already pushed to the edge by the Court of Owls, driven to the discovery that he has even more desperate depths to plumb. I have a feeling that they're going to pull it off.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Batman (2011) #15

Dec 13, 2012

Walk through the door (and while you're there, frame Capullo's haunting, magnificent opening page). I promise that nothing will be the same when you come out the other side.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Batman (2011) #16

Jan 16, 2013

And Batman #16 is scary because the good man, the man of skill and cunning has fundamentally misapprehended what is going on. Bruce insists to himself that he's shown up early, finally one step ahead, and that the Joker himself is within his grasp. He cannot see that he has become a dark knight errant, descending into hell in a quest to save what has already been lost.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Batman (2011) #17

Feb 15, 2013

And then go buy another. To ask for it back would simply be cruel.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Batman (2011) #20

May 13, 2013

In either case, it's a welcome sign that the somewhat minimalist “just the basics” approach to the Dark Knight might finally be falling out of fashion. (After all, running around in a cape isn't really the approach of a minimalist personality.) Batman has always lived in a larger than life world, and what makes Snyder's writing so extraordinary is the way that his Bruce Wayne is still so much himself in the middle of it all.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman (2011) #21

Jun 12, 2013

Every night for Batman is the very first night, and Batman #21 is something special in that it gives us a glimpse of what happens before the first first night, and a Bruce Wayne who not only isn't Batman yet, he isn't even quite Bruce Wayne. Yet.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman (2011) #23

Aug 15, 2013

Batman's world is a strange place. Let's keep it that way.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman / Superman (2013) #2

Jul 25, 2013

But I'm already willing to say that after Pak and Lee finish with Batman/Superman, I want an Earth 2 Catwoman series from them. It's okay. I'll wait.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman and Robin (2011) #0

Sep 14, 2012

It's entirely possible that Damian is a continuity bomb, a virus Grant Morrison slipped into the DC universe. He rebuilds the world around himself, and probably will never quite fit. If we're lucky, we'll get to watch the whole thing.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman and Robin (2011) #17

Feb 18, 2013

In the middle of upheaval, with more promised to be on the way, it's nice to be able to see everyone get to smile just once. Those of us who read Batman aren't exactly expecting the light to win, but even darkness needs contrast.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Batman and Robin (2011) #18

Mar 14, 2013

It's almost unbearable. As it should be.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman and Robin (2011) #19

Apr 10, 2013

Batman and Red Robin #19 is a busy comic. There are no fewer than three guest stars, two of whom are called out on the cover, but there's still apparently room for a couple of welcome surprises

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman Incorporated (2012) #3

Aug 23, 2012

If you're a Grant Morrison fan, which I think I've made clear I am, you owe it to yourself to be reading this title. (Although chances are that you already are.) If you're not a Morrison fan, then let me invite you to just dip your toe. Come in for the art — Damien's scowl, Bruce's powder-blue eyes, the way that Batman's silhouette dances across Matches Mallone's shades. The patterns are everywhere, but don't be afraid if you don't see them just yet. Stay just a bit longer. Turn the page. The answers are there, just out of reach.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman Incorporated (2012) #5

Nov 29, 2012

Grant Morrison's grand Batman tale may seem to be coming to a conclusion, but it's building up steam as it gets there. I'm looking forward to seeing what happens next.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Batman Incorporated (2012) #8

Feb 27, 2013

If you're the sort of person affected by acts of great sacrifice in the face of impossible odds, you'll find it moving. If you're the sort of person bothered by the depiction of acts of violence visited on a ten-year-old boy, you'll find it rather disturbing.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman Incorporated (2012) #13

Jul 31, 2013

Grant Morrison has been writing his Batman story for nearly seven years now, and taken by itself, Batman Incorporated #13 can almost seem an anticlimax. Everything happens so quickly, and it's all narrated after the fact, as Commisioner Gordon interrogates Bruce Wayne alone.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Batman: Li'l Gotham #1

Oct 31, 2012

So don't buy Li'l Gotham because you want to prove Dan Didio wrong. Buy it because DC should be encouraged to publish Dustin Nguyen's watercolors wherever and whenever they can. Because Batman should have a lighter side. And because, in the end, it's okay to have a little fun. As a good example for Damian.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Batman: The Dark Knight (2011) #16

Jan 30, 2013

And I haven't even gotten to The Mad Hatter. Is there a touch of Christopher Walken in his face and demeanor? Yes, but I think it's the platform shoes that make the package for me. I would not, however, recommend telling the man that to his face. It might not end well.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Batwing #19

Apr 3, 2013

But, happily, it's not an either/or world. With the sort of support DC is giving Batwing, as well as the newest Green Lantern, Simon Baz, maybe the return of a character like Nightrunner isn't too much to hope for. He'd be a great supporting character in a revamped Batwing series with an increased international focus. Something like the title that starts in earnest next month.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Birds Of Prey (2011) #12

Aug 22, 2012

At the end, we're left with Black Canary, Starling, and Katana standing over a grievously wounded Poison Ivy, trying to figure out what to do next. In another title, that moment might be a breaking point, a sign that the end has finally come, but in Birds of Prey, maybe, just maybe, it means that the team (and the title) has finally hit rock bottom, and that better things are on the way.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Code Monkey Save World #1

Oct 17, 2013

I'm pleased to say that I don't have any idea where Code Monkey Save World is going. But let me grab a blaster, brush up on my HTML, and throw on some Jonathan Coulton songs for clues, and I'm right there for the ride.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Comeback #1

Nov 21, 2012

Fortunately, then, I'm the sort of person who has a weakness for young men with tall hair and skinny ties who act more grizzled than they have any right to be. With titles like Manhattan Projects, Prophet, and even Invincible, Image Comics is quietly carving out a claim to be the home of the best science fiction comics being produced today. If Brisson and Walsh continue to build on a promising start, Comeback will be a worthy part of that conversation.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Constantine (2013) #1

Mar 20, 2013

Maybe it's not that John's less dark, maybe it's that we all look at the world through Constantine-colored glasses.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Detective Comics (2011) #14

Nov 12, 2012

It may not have the explosive audacity of Snyder and Capullo's Batman (Fabok's art in particular is solid and skillful rather than inspiring), but Detective Comics is delivering classic Batman in tone, character, and story. It's a welcome return to form for one of DC's flagship titles.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Detective Comics (2011) #27

Jan 9, 2014

History, impact, a few extra pages, and most important of all, outstanding content. Yes, it seems that DC really can learn, and deliver a celebration worthy of the event.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Dial H #15

Aug 8, 2013

But Dial H kinda did it. The highs were better than the lows. And while I can't recommend picking up #15 on its own, I can send you to the trade, and those first glorious issues. For many readers, that'll be enough, but a few of you will keep going. Let me know if you do, because chances are that you're my kind of people.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Doctor Who: Prisoners of Time #4

Apr 19, 2013

This is a unique opportunity to add a Doctor or two to your list of favorites. Bow ties are cool, but so are scarves, and umbrellas, and celery.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Earth 2 #9

Feb 8, 2013

Earth 2 covers a lot of ground, but it steadfastly refuses to be rushed. This is a virtue. Don't worry too much if you don't catch all the references to previous characters and continuities.3 The mythology Robinson and Scott are building is rich enough on its own to provide ample rewards to readers patient enough to let things unfold.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Earth 2 Annual #1

May 31, 2013

All of which is a long way of saying that Earth 2 Annual #1 is an excellent jumping-on point for a well-told story in a rich, unique, and yet insistently familiar world. Just as long as you're not expecting more Batman than is actually there.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
FF (2012) #7

May 16, 2013

Fantastic Four has always been a comic about a very unusual, very real family exploring and surviving the unimaginable. FF is that tradition at its best. Its very, very best.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
G.I. Joe (2013) #1

Feb 20, 2013

And out of all this, the celebrity angle might be much less objectionable than the decision to re-stage a version of real events stripped of all their context. After all, G.I. Joe was always a celebrity fantasy, even when its operations were “covert,” but even here, G.I. Joe #1 still feels like ground that Youngblood tread, without many rewards, twenty years ago.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Jupiter's Legacy #2

Jun 26, 2013

I won't spoil the turn the story takes on the final two pages, even if it's probably not that much of a surprise. After all, if you're paying attention, you know that you've read this story before, but it's still a pleasure to watch a pair of masters tell it again with every bit of their skill.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Nightwing (2011) #0

Sep 21, 2012

But, ultimately, somehow, Dick Grayson still works. It all feels right. To everyone except Dick, apparently, who from the start says that “Robin would be anything but permanent.” Which is no surprise, really. He's outgrown the cape by the time he gets to put it on.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Prophet (2012) #28

Sep 1, 2012

In fact — and this may sound like unusual praise, but in all honesty I wasn't expecting to be giving it — one of the best things I have to say about the book is that it doesn't really matter whether you have all the background or understand everything that's going on. The world of Prophet is far less interested in explaining itself than in going about the business of doing what it's doing. For a story of a broken universe, and a few people trying to put what they can back together, this is exactly as it should be.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Red Hood And The Outlaws #0

Sep 20, 2012

With Jason Todd finally making sense as a hero shaped by crime and violence beyond anyone else in the Bat-family, and DC's Zero Month quickly becoming the month of the Robins3, it's a bit surprising that the one place that Red Hood #0 falls flat is when Jason actually becomes Robin.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Samurai Jack #1

Oct 25, 2013

Is the comic quite as magical as the cartoon? No. Well, not yet anyway. But its good to have Jack back again, in whatever form we can get him.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Star Wars (2013) #1

Jan 9, 2013

My only real concern is that with the Star Wars license shifting to Marvel comics in the foreseeable future, this might end up being a title cut off before its time. But really, that's all the more reason to catch this series while you can. It'll be worth every page and every penny.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Swamp Thing (2011) #18

Mar 8, 2013

For this reviewer at least, an end was welcome. I'm happy to say it was worth it.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Talon #1

Oct 29, 2012

But this is a first issue! There's still plenty of time to smooth out the edges and fill in the details. For now, pick up Talon #1 for the action, but stay for the conspiracy theories. If Tynion keeps up the mix, we're in for a good time.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Teen Titans (2011) #0

Sep 26, 2012

What's really frustrating is that all of this could work if it weren't for the way being a member of the Teen Titans forces DC to try to hold onto the last bits of the old Tim — likable, plays well with others, still doesn't seem to quite know what to do with girls. A totally independent, wildly brilliant, tech savvy, sociopathic Tim Drake could be fascinating. He probably wouldn't be a team player, but he wouldn't be dull, either.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
The Red Ten #1

Jan 3, 2013

For example, Agatha Christie readers will remember that her novel isn't exactly about a death trap, at least not in the mechanical, Rube Goldbergian, Silver Age comic book sense. In Christie, there's a murderer among the ten. I'm pretty sure the same is true in The Red Ten, and that the first issue has sent some pretty clear signals about who it is. I'd be more excited about the series as a whole if I were more sure that those signals were intentional.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
The X-Files: Season 10 #1

Jun 19, 2013

I'm not entirely sure yet whether Season 10 of the X-Files will be as good, and as rewarding to longtime fans as, say, the extended comic seasons of Buffy the the Vampire Slayer. I can tell you that Mulder's deadpan still works, Scully is still the earnest, straightforward center of the goings-on, and it's still good to see Skinner's particular embodiment of a cross between Charlie Brown and a bulldog. Everyone (except the creators) is clearly in over their heads.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Wonder Woman (2011) #15

Dec 20, 2012

With Darkseid's son and Ares' greatest pupil on hand, that's a situation that can't last. And that's without even mentioning Diana's apparently oldest half-sibling, who spent the last 7,000 years tunneling his way out from the center of the Earth and is currently chilling in the Antarctic. Azzarello clearly has the long game in mind, and some big pieces on the board. It looks like they're just about ready to come into play. I'm (still) looking forward to it.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Wonder Woman (2011) #24

Oct 17, 2013

I imagine that one day Diana will get the opportunity fight for her sisters the way she tried to fight for their brothers in Hephaestus's forge. I look forward to reading that story.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
World's Finest (2012) #0

Sep 7, 2012

And I'll be the first to say that as a reader, the Worlds' Finest/Earth 2 take on superheroes is totally refreshing. It's a reminder that grittiness has as much to do with resolve, determination, and hand-to-hand heroism as it does with living in a world of corruption and compromise.

View Issue       View Full Review

Reviews for the Week of...

May

1st

April

More